Tattoos: The Fine Line Between Art and Health Risks

The art of tattooing, once associated with subcultures and informal groups, has now firmly entered the daily lives of millions of people. Body artwork has become a vibrant expression of individuality, and social media has turned tattoos into a real trend. However, despite their aesthetic appeal, tattoos carry certain health risks. Heavy metals contained in tattoo inks can accumulate in the body and cause allergic reactions, while non-compliance with sanitary norms during the application of tattoos increases the risk of infectious diseases. Additionally, the long-term effects on the immune and lymphatic systems are still not fully understood.

In this article, we will take a closer look at the tattooing process, the materials used, and the potential health risks. The aim of this article is to provide comprehensive information so you can weigh the pros and cons and make an informed decision about whether to get a tattoo. If you choose to remove a tattoo, we will also discuss the safest ways to do so.

Chemical Composition of Tattoo Inks

Tattoos are created using special dyes—pigments. These pigments are divided into two main types: organic and inorganic.

• Organic pigments are usually carbon-based and provide bright, saturated colours. However, they can cause allergic reactions and fade more quickly in sunlight.
• Inorganic pigments are made from metals and minerals. They are more resistant to fading, but some, such as lead, cadmium, and mercury compounds, can be toxic and cause serious health issues.

In addition to pigments, tattoo inks contain various additives, such as preservatives and stabilizers. Some of these can trigger allergic reactions and other health problems.

The Tattooing Process

During the tattooing process, a needle penetrates the outer layer of skin, called the epidermis, and injects pigment into the deeper layer—the dermis. What distinguishes these skin layers?

The Body’s Immune Response

The introduction of a foreign substance, in this case, pigment, triggers an immune response. When the skin is pierced by the needle and pigment is introduced, immune cells, such as macrophages, begin to work. They engulf the pigment particles that have been injected into the dermis, remaining there along with these particles. Initially, the particles are too large for them, which is why tattoos do not fade immediately.

This response can lead to inflammation, and although most people do not experience serious issues, some may have allergic reactions to the pigments, resulting in itching, redness, and swelling.

Over time, the dye breaks down into smaller particles, allowing macrophages to “transport” the pigment particles, and some may be eliminated through the lymphatic system, gradually leading to the loss of clarity of the tattoo.

Potential Health Risks Associated with Tattoos

Now, let’s discuss the risks associated with the tattooing process itself and what happens after the artwork is applied to the skin.

• Infectious Diseases: Using non-sterile tools or low-quality inks poses a risk of contracting hepatitis B, hepatitis C, HIV, Staphylococcus, and other infections. Even in professional studios, this risk cannot be entirely eliminated.
• Allergic Reactions: Tattoo inks can cause allergic reactions, manifesting as redness, itching, swelling, and blistering. Allergies may occur immediately after the procedure or several years later.
• Autoimmune Reactions: In some individuals, tattoos may trigger or exacerbate autoimmune conditions due to the immune response to the injected ink and potential inflammation.
• Scar Formation: Poorly executed tattoos, individual skin characteristics, or improper aftercare can lead to scar formation.
• Cancer Risks: Some studies associate tattoos with an increased risk of certain types of cancer. Heavy metals and other toxins contained in inks can accumulate in the body and negatively impact health.
• MRI Interference: Tattoos with metallic pigments may distort the results of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI).
• Psychological Aspects: An unsuccessful tattoo or a change in one’s attitude toward it over time may lead to psychological discomfort.

Heavy Metals in Tattoo Ink

Some tattoo inks contain heavy metals like lead, cadmium, mercury, copper, and chromium. When these metals enter the body, they can accumulate in organs and tissues, exerting long-term toxic effects. Heavy metals can also suppress the immune system, making the body more vulnerable to infections. Research has linked exposure to heavy metals with genetic mutations and an increased risk of cancer.

Below is a list of the most common heavy metals and their potential health effects:

• Lead: Damage to the nervous system and kidneys, reduced IQ, and reproductive issues.
• Cadmium: Kidney and lung damage, increased risk of cancer, osteoporosis.
• Mercury: Central nervous system damage, neurological disorders, issues with coordination, vision, and hearing.
• Chromium (excess): DNA damage, increased cancer risk, allergic reactions.
• Nickel: Allergic reactions, dermatitis.
• Cobalt: Toxic with prolonged exposure, may cause lung diseases.
• Copper (excess): Allergic reactions, liver and kidney damage, potential neurological issues.

Due to these risks, many countries have introduced strict regulations and limits on heavy metal content in tattoo inks. However, not all ink manufacturers comply with these standards.

Metal Distribution in Tattoo Ink by Color

Black tattoo inks primarily consist of carbon, which gives them a dark hue. Iron and titanium may be added to enhance the shade and characteristics. While the metal spectrum in black inks is generally narrower than in coloured inks, their presence cannot be entirely ruled out.

The following is a list of metals commonly found in various tattoo pigments, sorted by colour. Titanium is not listed, as it was found in high concentrations in almost every colour:

• Green: Chromium, manganese, iron, copper, bromine, barium, trace amounts of lead.
• Yellow: Chromium, iron, nickel, barium, trace amounts of lead.
• Blue: Copper, bromine.
• Red: Chromium, iron, nickel, barium.
• Brown: Chromium, iron, nickel, barium.
• Purple: Tungsten, iron, chromium.
• White: Low metal concentration.
• Orange: Low metal concentration.

The composition of inks can vary depending on the manufacturer and other factors.

Amount of Ink Absorbed by the Body During Tattooing

The risk levels increase with the amount of ink absorbed by the body. The amount of ink used for a tattoo varies depending on its size and complexity. Here is an approximate range:

• Small tattoo (5×5 cm): 0.5 to 1 ml.
• Medium tattoo (10×10 cm): 2 to 5 ml.
• Large tattoo (20×20 cm or more): 5 ml or more.

These values are approximate, as the actual amount of ink depends on colour density, shades used, and the tattoo artist’s technique.

How Long Can Metals from Tattoos Remain in the Body?

Research indicates that even after tattoo removal, metal residues may persist in the body, potentially causing long-term health effects. To remove heavy metals distributed throughout the body by the immune system before tattoo removal, a chelation procedure may be necessary.

Tattoo Industry Regulations in Canada

In Canada, tattoo industry regulation is still in its early stages. Unlike some European countries with strict controls on ink composition, Canada mainly focuses on sanitary standards and tattoo artists’ certification. While the qualification of the artist and adherence to hygiene protocols are crucial, as they help prevent the spread of viral and bacterial infections, attention to ink composition is equally important.

Control Over Tattoo Ink Composition in Canada

Canada has strict limits for heavy metals in cosmetics, such as 10 ppm of lead. However, monitoring these standards for tattoo inks, which also fall under cosmetic products, is not stringent enough. A study by the Canadian Consumer Product Safety Agency found that many tattoo ink samples significantly exceeded permissible levels of hazardous substances like lead, cadmium, and mercury. This highlights major gaps in quality control, posing health risks to consumers.

Tattoo inks are injected into the deep layers of the skin and remain there for life. The immune system attempts to remove these foreign substances, which may lead to the distribution of heavy metals throughout the body. Even trace amounts of these metals can accumulate in tissues and cause health problems. Given that tattoo inks are injected invasively, the current permissible limits for heavy metals in cosmetics may be insufficient.

The lack of effective quality control for tattoo inks presents significant health risks. Canada should increase government oversight in this industry, enforce stricter requirements for manufacturers and importers, and raise consumer awareness of the risks. In the current situation, consumers have limited control over the quality of inks used for tattoos.

Tattoo Removal Methods

If you decide to remove a tattoo, it’s essential to understand the mechanisms behind each removal method, as each has unique pros, cons, and contraindications. Always discuss these with your doctor to determine the best approach for your situation.

Laser Removal

• Advantages: Lasers are highly effective, especially for dark inks like black, as they can break down pigment particles into small fragments. The method is well-studied and generally provides reliable results.
• Considerations: Laser removal places a burden on the lymphatic system, as broken pigment particles are dispersed throughout the body. These particles may remain in lymph nodes, and their long-term effects are still under study. Light and coloured tattoos are more challenging to treat with lasers, often requiring additional sessions.

Chemical Removal

• Advantages: This method is relatively inexpensive and accessible, targeting the outer skin layers.
• Considerations: Chemical removal with acids or peels can irritate the skin and cause scarring. Allergic reactions and skin damage are common, especially with repeated applications. The method is often less effective for deep or old tattoos and may require supplemental laser treatment, limiting its versatility.

Microdermabrasion

• Advantages: This involves mechanically removing the outer skin layers with microcrystals, which can help fade a tattoo. It is less invasive and typically does not require anesthesia.
• Considerations: Effective mainly for surface tattoos, it often requires multiple sessions. There is also a risk of scarring and hypopigmentation.

Plasma Removal

• Advantages: Plasma treatment breaks down pigment particles similarly to laser removal but with fewer side effects and often less pain.
• Considerations: Despite being less invasive, plasma removal may yield uneven results and requires fine-tuning for each individual. Current research is limited, so more data on long-term effects and potential side effects is needed.

Osmosis with Saline Solution

• Advantages: A gentler method that reduces the risk of deep skin damage, making it suitable for those who may not tolerate other methods.
• Considerations: This method does not guarantee complete removal and may be less effective for dense pigment or older tattoos. Multiple sessions are typically required, and it’s more effective for lightening rather than complete removal.

Each tattoo removal method has specific characteristics, and individual preferences and needs should be considered. Combining methods may yield the best results. Consulting a qualified specialist is recommended to determine the optimal tattoo removal strategy for your case.

Conclusion

Tattoos are an art form that allows for unique self-expression, but they also carry significant health risks. It’s essential to understand that tattoo inks, especially those containing heavy metals, can accumulate in the body and lead to various issues, including allergic reactions, inflammation, and potential long-term effects on the lymphatic and immune systems. Hygiene standards, the artist’s professionalism, and control over ink ingredients play a crucial role in minimizing these risks. Before getting a tattoo or starting a removal process, weigh the pros and cons, and ensure that your chosen methods are safe and meet modern standards. Being aware of all potential outcomes will help you make a well-informed and safe decision.

Russian

Health Canada. Guidance on Heavy Metal Impurities in Cosmetics [Internet]. Ottawa (ON): Government of Canada; 2012 [cited 2024 Nov 4]. Available from: https://www.canada.ca/en/health-canada/services/consumer-product-safety/reports-publications/industry-professionals/guidance-heavy-metal-impurities-cosmetics.html#a32

Health Canada. Cosmetic Ingredient Hotlist: Prohibited and Restricted Ingredients [Internet]. Available from: https://www.canada.ca/en/health-canada/services/consumer-product-safety/cosmetics/cosmetic-ingredient-hotlist-prohibited-restricted-ingredients/hotlist.html

Forte G, Petrucci F, Cristaudo A, Bocca B. Market survey on toxic metals contained in tattoo inks. Sci Total Environ. 2009 Nov 15;407(23):5997-6002. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2009.08.034

Interclinical. Toxins in tattoo inks and health impacts [Internet]. Available from: https://interclinical.com.au/newsletter/toxins-in-tattoo-inks-and-health-impacts/

JCAD. Tattoos: Medical Risks of Body Ink [Internet]. Available from: https://jcadonline.com/tattoos-medical-risks-body-ink/